Medicare ain't so efficient
John Stossel tears down the Medicare efficiency myth:
[L]ast month on "20/20" producer Miguel Sancho and I reported on Medicare’s $34 trillion in unfunded liabilities, on how Medicare is a prime example of government promising MUCH more -- that it is prepared to deliver. But the Obama administration has succeeded in promoting the fiction that Medicare is a shining example of government working well. Statists suggests that because Medicare only spends two or three percent of its budget on overhead, that means it's a smoothly running machine. Bevan cites recent columns by Jonathan Alter and Paul Krugman, and “West Wing” fans will remember Jimmy Smits’ Matt Santos making the same argument in the famous “live debate” episode.Over at QandO, McQ points out a recent warning from the CBO on entitlement spending: "Almost all of the projected growth in federal spending other than interest payments on the debt comes from growth in spending on the three largest entitlement programs–Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security."Bevan argues persuasively that Medicare’s low overhead is the product of government accounting sleight-of-hand. But there’s a bigger point – the connection between “low” administrative costs and staggeringly HIGH levels of fraud and waste. As Michael Cannon at the Cato Institute and Regina Herzlinger at Harvard Business School have pointed out, much of the 10 to 20 percent of private insurance administrative costs goes to preventing fraud. Private insurers, you see, care about whether or not they lose money. Medicare, with its unlimited claim on the public purse, does not. It's only taxpayer money, after all.
The results are predictable, but breathtaking nonetheless: an estimated $68 billion (with a B) in outright Medicare fraud every year (About $3 billion in Miami-Dade county ALONE.) On top of that, according to well-respected Dartmouth researchers, roughly a third of Medicare's total $400 billion annual spending goes to procedures which were medically unnecessary.
Also, an audit of Social Security shows that millions in benefits are being paid out dead people. Gotta love government.



Comments
I completely agree. Being a Registered Nurse who works with a majority of patients who have Medicare I can tell you Medicare overall is just another big government mess.
I work for a private company led by an entrepreneur and our company is reimbursed by Medicare and overall the industry I am in saves taxpayers money by at a cheaper cost keeping Seniors at home, out of the hospital & nursing homes, and educating them on their conditions and medications. So what does President Obama want to do? Cut funding to the one area of healthcare that I think actually makes sense and give that money to big unions in hospitals which need to be completely reformed.
I agree Medicare and healthcare need "change" but it needs the right kind of change like getting the government the heck out of it!!!
Posted by: Elizabeth Christian | July 2, 2009 11:25 PM