« State Budget Bunk | Main | 10th District Debate Open Thread »

Chicago columnist defends nanny state

After having their nanny and police state laws mocked by Radley Balko, a columnist from the Chicago Tribune, Mary Schmich, fires back and defends the city:

[Balko] whimpered about our police cameras, our tax on bottled water, our high cigarette and alcohol taxes, and, in the way of many a 10-year-old, seemed to equate the fact that we can't have whatever fun we want whenever we want it with an assault on our basic freedom. But where some people see paternalism, we weirdos believe that most of Chicago's rules help turn unruly city dwellers into civilized citizens. Big cities are like big families-put a lot of people into a small space and somebody has to be charged with the power to say "Stop it."
The columnist also leaves us with a list of laws she would like to see in place:
In fact, I wouldn't mind a few more restrictions on city life. For example:

•A ban on barbecue lighter fluid. If you have ever gagged on your neighbors' fumes as they doused their charcoal and torched it, or if you've ever cruised past the barbecue thickets along the lakefront in July, you know this stuff's a killer.

•A ban on operating heavy construction machines on Saturdays. A triple fine for violating the ban on Saturday mornings in summer. No exemptions for the megamansion builders accustomed to buying their way out of rules.

The fine on violators would be donated to repair the hearing and sanity of neighbors whose summer tranquility has been sacrificed to bulldozers.

•A ban on air conditioners that run round the clock from the day the heater goes off in spring until it goes back on in fall. Fellow citizens: What's wrong with fresh air? And a little sweat is the whole purpose of summer.

•An enforced ban on honking just because you're in a hurry. The fine doubles if you honk at someone who is hypermiling. Hypermiling, in case you haven't caught the craze, is driving that maximizes your mileage, such as coasting toward stop signs.

•A ban on bicycling on city streets or any busy path (think: lakefront) wearing iPod earbuds or headphones. This is for the protection not only of hapless pedalers singing along with Coldplay, but also the people in their path.

Other worthy bans:

•No more taking fistfuls of paper napkins when you need only one.

•No more confiscating the only free table in a busy cafe before you even get in the long line to place your order. If this ban is approved, I'll be in jail in 24 hours.

And, finally, some words that should be banned because of overuse: "Awesome." "Sweet." "Nanny state."

How dare we mock such a progressive and civilized city. This is column by Schmich should be the poster child for the Club for Growth's new Dumb Laws blog.

Comments

This columnist is a real piece of work. She needs to find reality.
Dark Knight

I suggest a ban on columists who think they are so smart that they can run other people's lives.

Perhaps a ban on nosy busybodies with nothing better to do than bitch and moan about the freedoms of others.

I propose a ban on idiots. Maybe with this ban, the ones put up here (and elsewhere) would never have been thought up.

Post a comment