McDonough: A Failed City Government
[UPDATE 5/29/08] The Herald picked upon the story:
Riffey said the main problem with the budget is the fact that revenues have decreased dramatically and the city's expenditures are exceeding its revenues.Mayor Copeland has no ideas and is looking tothe city ocuncil for an answer.
James Moss, McDonough planning commissioner and resident, said he has talked to some city residents and they are not happy about the situation.Moss also offered a few alternatives to the city's financial woes.
"Before there is a tax increase, the city needs to do two things: one, demonstrate that it can handle money through audits and written financial policies; and two, show how it has tightened its own belt.The simple lesson is prior planning and budget forecasting. Lack of revenues was predicted; the economy slowdown is not a surprise change. Fiscal responsibility is what they lack."This includes asking the HR [human resources] department and department heads to make a critical evaluation of their budgets, so that everything is put on the table, along with re-evaluating the $37,000 monthly payment the city is paying for the proposed park on Jonesboro Road and any other similar projects."
[Original Post: 5/27/08]
The Henry Times featured a piece on the failure to the City of McDonough to yet adopt a 2008 budget.
The city has been operating on a provisional budget since the first of the year and the Council has until May 31 to adopt a final operating budget. Mr. James Lee, City Administrator, gave his report that included a difficult challenge to the council.He sees only two choices for them; to do nothing and leave the budget as it now is and raise property taxes by 88% (a 2 mil increase instead of the previous 1.45 mil), or a combination of a reduction of personnel and still raise taxes by the original 1.45 mil, or 64%.
Lee was quick to point out that no decisions have been made about personnel, despite many rumors, and that the city Human Resources Director, Carla Tuck, and the department heads have not even been consulted on this. This recommendation is only one being made.
Lee did continue to say he supported the combination recommendation of a 64% tax increase and reducing city personnel.
Earlier in the evening, the city’s auditor, Jimmy Whitaker, had reported that as of December 31, 2007, the city of McDonough General Fund had overspent $1,385,000 in expenditures over revenues. Councilmember Sandra Vincent understated the problem by saying she, "did not feel that we have exercised due diligence in this matter."
The job of a city manager whose salary is greater than the governor's surely includes fiscal responsibility. The city council allocates funds and they are also guilty of extravagant spending. In all, the city is awash in fiscal failure.
Details not told in the Times include the fact McDonoughis involved in a law suit over impact fees. State law requires a study of the service area before the fees can be imposed. The city adopted the County's study, which included all unicorporated areas. No study was performed on the service area inside McDonough's city limits. The lawsuit charges collection of impact fees within McDonough are therefore illegal.
Impact fees were adopted under the Craig administration several years ago. They have been continued under the Copeland administration. At present the Impact Fee budget account is overdrawn in excess of $100,000.
If the city loses this lawsuit, all fees collected since their inception must be returned. It is not clear exactly how much financial liability the city would face.
There is also the matter of Gail Notti Park, which costs the city between $36,000 - $40,000 per month. The debt resulted from a plan to create a mini-Callaway Gardens adjacent to the councilwoman's property.
We must not overlook the stockpile of now-surplus Chevrolet Caprice automobiles. Last year the city replaced police department vehicles with new Dodge vehicles.
Let's recount:
McDonough General Fund had overspent $1,385,000 in expenditures over revenues.And the City's response? RAISE TAXES.
McDonough's Impact Fee budget account is overdrawn in excess of $100,000Outcome of a lawsuit could cost McDonough $Millions
McDonough's Gail Notti Park costs about $40,000 per month
McDonough's fleet of new cars created a surplus of vehicles



Comments
Its them thats got is them that wants more.
McDonough is no different than any other governing body in Henry County . If they aren't greedy and corrupt before they are elected they soon will be and I know of only two exceptions right now.
And Larry I will and do publicly apologize for the sarcastic post concerning my feelings toward the Old Guard I do not apologize for my commitment but my tone was not as it should have been so if you will accept it I do apologize. The Old Guard unit is very special to me and my family. My son left the unit just a few days before 9/11 and was very distraught that seven of his closet friends were killed at the Pentagon ... the Old Guard also does duty there. As you may or may not understand when your children are making the sacrifice for our county that they make it can be a sensitive area in your life. So again please accept my apology for my rudeness.
Don Henderson
Posted by: Don | May 24, 2008 08:52 PM
Don, no offense taken. I do understand.
Posted by: Larry Stanley | May 24, 2008 10:27 PM
This situation about Ms. Notti and her gardens is the same situation with Ms. Mathis and her battlefield. They are both a waste of taxpayer money. They want something and they get it with little or no obstruction from either the city council or the commissioners. It is as though they attended the same school of thought. Maybe the taxpayers will have something to say when election time comes around.
Time will tell.
The Doctor
Posted by: The Doctor | May 24, 2008 11:12 PM
I have been noticing a steady decline in the McDonough city government for the seven years that I lived in the city. I am glad that I got out of there.
Dark Knight
Posted by: Dark Knight | May 25, 2008 04:13 PM
I think the solution to muni debt is product placement. We could have a Coca-Cola bridge. Or a Delta Airlines park. Or put the UPS logo on the police cars. Print the Office Depot logo on traffic tickets. We have to get creative. Debt is nothing to fear in our capitalist system!
Of course, I am writing this tongue-in-cheek, but I am somewhat serious about the concept. Of course uptight liberals, neo-Marxists, and other populists won't like it.
Posted by: Robbie | May 27, 2008 09:13 AM
Robbie
all the more reason to do it if for nothing more than putting a burr under their saddle.
Don
Posted by: Don | May 27, 2008 03:25 PM
Sounds familiar doesn't it.
They learn well. As stated before follow the money.
The Doctor
Posted by: The Doctor | May 27, 2008 06:21 PM
The Henry County Times Hey Henry post on this topic:
Now, that is a mouthful!Posted by: Larry Stanley | May 29, 2008 05:00 PM
"I haven't talked to anybody who isn't willing and prepared for a tax increase," said Councilwoman Gail Notti. "We've had 10 years of not raising taxes, we have no other choice."
Does anyone see how absurd her thought process is? Isn't this the same person who wanted a butterfly house?
Posted by: Bright Knight | May 29, 2008 08:12 PM
This is the same council woman who wanted a Gone With the Wind theme park in Clayton County.
The post on the Hey Henry is definitely a mouth full and sounds like someone who has their numbers together.
The Doctor
Posted by: The Doctor | May 29, 2008 08:48 PM
Doc
if you remember when they were trying to sell this boondoggle in Clayton County they ,the commission was touting the fact that the, I think was 25 million, bond was going to be for the parks and recreation,libraries and transportation issues. with a small portion going to the Gone With The Wind project.
Turns out when you started reading the small print the 2.6 million would be divided among the parks and recreation , libraries and transportation the remainder would go to the "Wind" both figuratively and literally.
Well if you can't stick'em in one county move on to the next. Maybe Madam Butterfly will wind up in eventually work her way on down to south Ga.
Posted by: Don | May 30, 2008 08:05 AM
OOPS
hit post instead of preview but I have been accused of doing that before.
To finish does anyone else see the mentality of the governing bodies in the positions of power.
"we've not raised taxes in 10 years,we have no other choice" I haven't had a raise in 11 years so I have to make choices. Of course politicians do Notti understand this principle they think that all of us get raises every year and they have been so very benevolent to allow us the privilege of keeping what WE earned so now it is not out of line for them to hold out their grubby hands and say gimme.
I think the time has come for government to tighten its belt not tighten the noose around our necks and wallet. I don't know about the rest of you but I'm tired of seeing the government drive better cars,have prettier lawns,better outside lighting,better and more expensive shrubs,colder air conditioning in the summer, warmer heat in the winter and all the other luxuries we can't afford.
And that is without even starting on the department heads that don't even have a department to head and the directors that don't direct.
I feel shameful that I am starting to want a bronze plaque with my name on it that says "This facility was paid for with funds extorted from Don".
Doctor you don't think I could be becoming a politician do you?
Posted by: Don | May 30, 2008 08:28 AM
Don,
I hope you don't catch that
disease sir.
The Doctor
Posted by: The Doctor | May 30, 2008 05:40 PM
I work at the City of McDonough and I have never seen so much back biting and bickering as well as tax payer money being spent on stupid things like this Butterfly Wonderland that no one on the City Council seems to oppose or question. I hear about $12 million will be spent on that Butterfly Oasis, mostly taxpayer money and still no outcry from anyone.
The County golf course cost the county taxpayers about $25 million and no outcry there either.
Not all, but most of the City of McDonough officials are dysfunctional and should not be in office but even with the Butterfly Park Ms Notti was voted back in office and the dysfunctional dimwits continue to stab each other in the back as they fight over who knows what. The continuance of creating job titles for people that do nothing all day is another problem without any Council members or the Mayor questioning these positions.
Between our City government and the City Tourism department I see no where else but 'down hill fast' for this entire City and its officials, all at the taxpayers expense.
Posted by: ugottaloveit | June 1, 2008 11:00 AM
Don't forget the over $8 million spent for Nash Farm.
You are correct in that it will be down hill all the way for the City if changes and I mean real changes are not made. Government waste of any kind has got to stop if we the taxpayers are going to see any daylight.
The Doctor
Posted by: The Doctor | June 1, 2008 10:37 PM
Why is the City of McDonough officials allowed to waste taxpayer money on things like butterfly parks, job positions for do nothing employees and entire departments that should have been eliminated years ago while at the same time they claim to be broke, in the red, and are not able to balance a budget? Their Tourism department is a joke too and should have been eliminated a long time ago.
I know Nash cost $8 million plus additional money to relocate a historic house but not sure what the price tag was on that.
Seems like our City officials are either dumb as a rock, blind as a bat or part of the good old boy system of allowing certain employees, certain departments and certain projects to go unchecked. If you are not part of that good old boy network you might as well hang it up and either give up or get fed up and move out.
Posted by: ugottaloveit | June 2, 2008 06:24 AM
They are part of the good ole buddy system and old family network. The house cost $32,000 to move to Nash Farm. And it was the
Adam C. Sloan house built in 1840. Col.Zachry moved into it in late Dec. 1903 and passed away there in Feb. 1906. It was always known as the Sloan House to people from McDonough. It should have remained in or near the City for this fact.
Posted by: The Doctor | June 2, 2008 09:07 PM